LABORING FOR A LIVING
Labor Day looms ahead on September 4th. Do you have your labor
story ready to go, so you can enjoy the long weekend that
symbolizes the end of summer for all of overworked America? If
the answer is no, don't sweat it. This week's University of
Cincinnati e-briefing offers a broad look at labor and working,
so you can get your story filed in time to enjoy the holiday as
well.
Table of contents
1. Labor changes over the years
A. The birth of Labor Day
B. Overtime for everyone?
2. Labor differences around the world
A. The union view: Europe v. the U.S.
B. View from the U.K.
C. Cultural differences toward weekends and travel
D. An international co-op's experience
E. Labor leadership depends on integration of
cultures
3. America's labor market today
A. More to life than work
B. Working for the little guys has advantages
C. A better deal
D. Productivity doesn't necessarily equal more free time
E. Bottom-rung jobs still hard to fill
F. High-tech shortages continue
G. Don't forget the underworked
4. What's ahead for workers and unions
A. Predictions for the next decade
B. Overworked Americans: a solution
C. Will fewer hours ever fly? A second opinion
D. Union influence on Capitol Hill
E. The future impact of robotics
1. LABOR CHANGES OVER THE YEARS
A. THE BIRTH OF LABOR DAY
In many other countries, Labor Day is celebrated on May Day (May
1), according to labor historian Jim Cebula of UC's Raymond
Walters College. Although May Day is now just another day in the
United States, the U.S. labor movement in its early days used May
1 as a day to highlight labor issues. For example, many of the
early worker riots in America broke out around May 1. And the
movement to make the eight-hour day the legal work day was
launched on May 1, 1886.
The idea for a U.S. Labor Day is credited to Peter McGuire, a
carpenter's union leader who suggested a celebration be held to
honor workers in 1882. A workers' parade in New York City on
Sept. 5, 1882, carried out his concept. The idea for a Labor Day
spread rapidly. Congress created the national holiday in 1894.
"Symbolically, the idea behind the origins of Labor Day is
that workers are as important as management, business owners and
business," said Cebula. contact: 513-745-5654
B. OVERTIME FOR EVERYONE?
UC sociologist David J. Maume Jr. says eliminating the exemption
for salaried workers from the Fair Labor Standards Act could ease
the burden on overworked Americans. The law mandates
time-and-a-half for hourly workers who work more than 40 hours a
week. When the Fair Labor Standards Act was approved in the
1930s, only 16 percent of the U.S. workforce was exempt
from the overtime requirement. Today 40 percent of American
workers are exempt. "Obviously this has taken place with the
decline of blue collar jobs," said Maume, director of the UC Kunz
Center for the Study of Work & Family. "But it also means a lot
of American workers are required to work as much as their
employer demands without receiving extra compensation."
contact: 513-556-4713
2. LABOR DIFFERENCES AROUND THE WORLD
A. UNION VIEWS: EUROPE VS. THE U.S.
UC associate professor of management Rajan Kamath, who studies
international competitiveness, believes American labor unions
could benefit if they became more like their European
counterparts. "In places like Holland and Germany, the union
means something entirely different than it does here," Kamath
says. "They are a very strong part of the work environment. They
have made the transition from the shop floor to the board room,
and now they have a very strong tradition of labor participation
in company corporate management."
The European model has already gained a foothold in some U.S.
industries. Northwest Airlines was forced to give 30 percent of
its equity to its pilots' union to guarantee its survival. But
bustling industries, such as high-tech, aren't likely to see much
in the way of unionization. "None of those jobs are union jobs.
They're all white-collar jobs, and they all have the stock option
bug," Kamath says. "Each guy working there has a little piece of
paper that every morning represents tens of thousands of dollars
more or less than the previous day, depending on what the
market does." contact: 513-556-7132
B. VIEW FROM THE UK
Renee Binyon, founder of INCONET Limited, a firm in the United
Kingdom which provides freelance management and training, says
the concept of a "job for life" is dimming. The clear upward
trend is toward freelance, contract and portfolio work. Binyon
cited the following figures: In the United Kingdom, 90 percent of
workplaces subcontract one or more services, and 40 percent use
fixed-term contract employees. Thirteen percent use freelance
workers. If the trend continues, that means that over 5 million
Britains could embark on independent professional careers in the
next 5 years. Across Europe, 9 million people now run companies
from home compared with 2 million in 1997.
The challenges these workers face are the same: isolation. In
a survey carried out by INCONET.com, 50 percent of independent
consultants and trainers want more contact with others to share
ideas and innovations, form alliances and to gain support. Many
have contact with clients but lack peer support. A related
challenge for the self-employed: keeping up with trends in
their field. "The human touch is vital for freelancers even while
technology is the engine driving flexibility and
cost-effectiveness," said Binyon. contact via Kate Rowland,
011-44-1761-463371; press@inconet.com
C. CULTURAL DIFFERENCES TOWARD WEEKENDS AND TRAVEL
Between her personal and professional life, Professor Urmila Ghia
has seen first-hand the cultural differences which affect workers
around the world. "In India, working a half day on Saturday is
typical in most companies and businesses," said Ghia. In
Germany, there is a much different approach toward extra work and
its impact on families. "When employees have to be out of town
for professional travel, not only is their travel cost covered,
but the employee is paid at 150 percent," said Ghia. She
explained that families typically undergo a hardship while the
employee is away, and often encounter additional costs during the
period of absence. "For example, the children miss their father,
and this places some burden on the mother, or vice versa."
contact: 513-556-4612
D. AN INTERNATIONAL CO-OP'S EXPERIENCE
Andrea Miller, a 22-year-old UC co-op student from Castalia,
Ohio, has been gaining exposure to a work culture that is more
flexible and less overtime-oriented than the United States. She
is on assignment working for Adam Opel AG -- InternationalTechnical Development Center in Russelsheim, Germany through UC's
International Co-op Program from March to September 2000. Staff
members work either 35-hour or 40-hour weeks, depending on their
contracts. Miller has been impressed with the vacation and
flex-time policies she sees in the German workplace.
"Employees have 30 days vacation (six weeks). Flex-time is
available if someone wants to take an afternoon or a couple of
days off. As a 'Praktikant' (student co-op), I have two days
vacation per month." She adds, "The German work ethic is much
more laid back. I don't at all mean to say that they fall behind
in work or don't do a good job. It's just a different atmosphere.
German workers are much less apt to work overtime on the same
scale that we do in the U.S. They value their free time in the
evenings and on the weekends." contact: (011) 49-6142-762-318;
andrea.miller@de.opel.com
E. LABOR LEADERSHIP DEPENDS ON INTEGRATION OF CULTURES
UC Professor Estela Matriano is international executive director
of the World Council for Curriculum and Instruction (WCCI), a
nongovernmental organization of the United Nations. She
has worked with companies such as Chiquita International Company
and others to provide diversity training and education on
multicultural issues. Matriano says Americans need to learn
how to interact with people in the workplace who speak different
languages and who come from different cultural backgrounds.
"We have an increasing number of Hispanic/Latino workers in
the restaurant industry in Cincinnati. Sometimes, we may think
they're impolite because they don't respond to a request, but
it's because they don't speak English. I know someone who was
hired to act as an interpreter. This kind of capability is
becoming necessary in the labor market."
"Georgetown, Kentucky was a monocultural city when the Toyota
plant was built in 1985. The Georgetown folks at Toyota contacted
Travelers Aid International Institute in the '80s about a
training course on Japanese culture and language. Now, Georgetown
is an active and vibrant community. You never know what can
happen in terms of globalization." contact: 513-556-3573
3. AMERICA'S LABOR MARKET TODAY
A . MORE TO LIFE THAN WORK
"We need to find something we can do above and beyond our pay
jobs, something more rewarding. We need to think of creating
meaningful leisure for ourselves and not invest so much
time and energy and spirit into our paid jobs," says Joanne
Bridgett Ciulla, author of "The Working Life: The Promise and
Betrayal of Modern Work."
Ciulla is Coston Family Chair in Leadership and Ethics at the
University of Richmond. In her latest book, Ciulla argues that
work promises more than it can deliver. "Americans define
themselves through their jobs, which can be devastating in
today's changing workplace. When large corporations downsized in
the mid '90s, upper middle class employees lost their jobs in
droves. These were people who always had job security and who
worked for good companies like AT&T and Xerox. They put their
whole lives into the organization. Their friends were their
coworkers. Unemployment was a devastating social death for them."
contact: 804-320-2525
B. WORKING FOR THE LITTLE GUYS HAS ADVANTAGES
For a long time, economists trivialized the impact of small
businesses on economic growth. In fact, small, entrepreneurial
and family businesses have been the engine of U.S. economic
growth and promise to continue to be a significant source of
jobs, innovation and economic expansion, according to Charles H.
Matthews, UC associate professor of management and
director of UC's Small Business Institute. "The explosive growth
in e-commerce has fueled the need for more employees in both new
and old firms," Matthews says. Small companies also offer
advantages to their workers, including more relaxed work
environments, faster decision-making, greater opportunity and the
potential for profit-sharing as the firm grows. contact:
513-556-7123
C. A BETTER DEAL
The success of the labor movement and the strong economy have
combined to create much better working conditions for most
Americans. That includes a feeling for workers of greater
fairness. Suzanne Masterson, a UC assistant professor of
management, researches the subject of fairness in the workplace.
Masterson says that labor unions have become less of a presence
at companies as treatment towards workers becomes more fair, a
trend reinforced by government action through regulatory agencies
like OSHA. Also, employees are empowered by the very
strong labor market, and can easily leave unfair employment
situations for more favorable ones.
A heightened sense of fairness in the workplace may benefit
organizations as well. "Recent research suggests that by training
managers to be more fair, companies cut down on the incidents
of employee theft," Masterson says. "If organizations are being
forced to be more fair, there's also something in it for them. It
can come back and affect their bottom line." contact:
513-556-7125
D. PRODUCTIVITY DOESN'T NECESSARILY EQUAL MORE FREE
TIME
One of Alan Greenspan's favorite measures of U.S. economic health
is the labor productivity rate. Workers produce more as it rises,
yet at the same time, it seems workers are having to work more
and more hours. Why? UC professor of economics Charles Berry says
it's not a cause-and-effect relationship. "Workers are more
productive, meaning the value of their work per hour goes up,
but they may also be choosing to work more to earn a higher
income. It's their choice," Berry says. As a sidelight, Berry
agrees that most of the gains have come through improved
technology. In the 10th year of economic expansion, aren't we
nearing a point of diminishing returns from those kinds of gains?
"It hasn't happened yet and may not for a while," Berry says. "If
you go back to other (technological) advances, it often takes 30
years or more for their effect to diminish, so we're still at the
early end of this." contact: 513-556-2624
E. BOTTOM-RUNG JOBS STILL HARD TO FILL
"On the bottom end of the job scale, there are tons of jobs
available. High school students can find jobs if they're willing
to work," says UC Business Technologies Professor Sandy Kahn.
Kahn says a common frustration for Greater Cincinnati employers
is that workers aren't prepared to do the job. "There's a real
demand for manpower, a lot of physical laborworkers needed to
wait on people and workers needed to cook the food. They need to
know how to come to work and make a commitment to the work."
Kahn says he's beginning to view the fast food industry as a
training ground for skilled workers, with benefits that never
were available for the teens who flipped burgers a generation
ago. "Companies like McDonald's and Wendy's are offering bonuses
to workers who can talk a friend into joining the staff. They're
willing to train young employees for management positions
while they provide them with traditional fringe benefits like
vacations, medical coverage and investment opportunities."
contact: 513-556-0371
F. HIGH-TECH ALSO SUFFERING SHORTAGES
UC Business Technologies Professor Sanford Kahn says labor
shortages in the Midwest affect employers searching for skilled
workers. "In terms of high-tech areas, there's a real shortage.
You can't just hire someone off the street. There's a real
shortage of nurses, and there simply are not enough people
available with the skills that employers need. Clerical jobs have
changed to high-tech jobs, but they're high-tech jobs at low pay,
such as data entry. Jobs in construction management are
unbelievable in terms of growth." contact: 513-556-0371
G. DON'T FORGET THE UNDERWORKED
While many Americans are feeling overworked, there is a
significant minority at the other end of the spectrum who would
like to work more but can't find full-time jobs, emphasizes UC
sociologist David J. Maume Jr., director of the Kunz Center for
the Study of Work & Family. "There is a segment of the U.S.
workforce that is underworked, and these are people who have
gotten downsized to part-time positions as employers have cut
back to save on the expenses of benefits," he says. About 10-15
percent of the labor force are working part-time but would like
full-time jobs. "We have seen growth at both ends of the tails --
more overworked Americans but also more underworked."
contact: 513-556-4713
4.WHAT'S AHEAD FOR WORKERS AND UNIONS
A. PREDICTIONS FOR THE NEXT DECADE
Kristin Accipiter, media affairs manager for the Society for
Human Resource Management, says her organization predicts:
1.) An even tighter labor market starting in 2010
when Baby Boomers begin an exodus out of the labor market. With
fewer younger workers to replace the departing Boomers, employers
will seek to retain older workers rather than retire
them.
2.) More employers will offer eldercare benefits for
middle-aged workers with elderly parents.
3.) Employers will lengthen the retirement age to
accommodate healthier older workers who choose not to retire.
4.) America's youth culture will be replaced by a "gray"
culture, and older workers will be greatly valued.
One society survey found that 97 percent of HR professionals
believe that older workers are reliable and thorough in their
work; 81 percent believe that older workers are interested in
learning new tasks; and 94 percent report that older workers do
not miss time from work because of health problems. contact:
703-535-6047; http://www.shrm.org
B. OVERWORKED AMERICANS: A SOLUTION
If the French can shorten their work week to 35 hours without
sacrificing pay and benefits, why can't the U.S. do the same? UC
sociologist David J. Maume Jr., director of the Kunz Center for
the Study of Work & Family thinks that the day may come sooner
than you imagine -- within the next 20 years. "Remember that the
eight-hour day was considered unlikely in the time of our
grandparents, too. I don't see a shorter work week coming this
year or next year or even under the next president, but I think
there may be some serious discussion not too far into the future.
Whenever we have cut back the work week, employers have been able
to increase productivity through technological innovation. This
can happen again." contact: 513-556-4713
C. WILL FEWER HOURS EVER FLY? A SECOND OPINION
It's been more than 60 years since Congress passed a law to
protect American workers from long work hours and established the
eight-hour work day/40-hour work week with time-and-a-half for
overtime. While much of the rest of the industrialized world,
particularly Europe, Canada and Australia, has long worked under
a 35-hour work week standard, it is unlikely that U.S. businesses
will ever follow suit, says Jim Cebula, a labor historian at the
UC's Raymond Walters College. Reducing work hours has not been
seriously discussed since the 1970s, he says. "The closest thing
we have is flex time, which has become more common." contact:
513-745-5654
D. UNION INFLUENCE ON CAPITOL HILL
Labor unions have long been cited as one of the most powerful
lobbying groups working the Congressional ranks. But UC assistant
professor of political science Carl Rhodes says labor's biggest
power comes at the ballot box, not through lobbying campaigns.
"What really changes is who is in control of Congress," Rhodes
says. "You may be getting the same sit-down sessions (with
Congress members) that you've always gotten, but it's not going
to have as much impact if you're not having them with the party
in control." contact: 513-556-3394
E. THE FUTURE IMPACT OF ROBOTICS
Ernie Hall, director of the UC Center for Robotics Research, said
robots have made a billion dollar impact on the U.S. economy, but
that's only the beginning. "Today's robotic machines are
faster, cheaper, more reliable and safer," said Hall. "The
knowledge base is increasing. More attention is being given by
industry to robots, vision and motion controls. New areas of
usage are emerging for service robots, remote manipulators and
automated guided vehicles." Feasibility studies show decreasing
costs for robots and healthy rates of return for a variety of
robotic applications. However, the road from inspiration to
successful application can be long and difficult. "A greater
emphasis on 'mechatronics' is needed in our universities. More
cooperation between government, industry and universities is
needed to speed the development of intelligent robots that will
benefit industry and society." On the homefront, Hall noted robot
lawn mowers are now available for under $800. contact:
513-556-2730
Click here to view previous UC e-briefings.
E-mail reillymb@email.uc.edu if you would like to become a regular recipient of UC's e-briefings. Please provide your name, media affiliation, snail-mail address, e-mail address, phone and fax number.