UC Research Examines Masculinity and Sexuality in Sport
Preliminary research out of the University of Cincinnati is providing a rare look at the construction of masculinity on the covers of mainstream and gay-themed sports magazines. The research by Jodi Stooksberry and J. A. Carter, both doctoral students in the UC Department of Sociology, will be presented on Aug. 10, at the 108th annual meeting of the American Sociological Association in New York, N.Y.
Stooksberry and Carter did a comparative analysis of two sports magazines: Sports Illustrated, one of the nations most recognized mainstream sports magazines, and Compete. Published out of Tempe, Ariz., Compete calls itself the worlds first gay sports magazine.
The researchers wanted to examine similarities and differences in the construction of masculinity on the front covers of the two magazines. They say their examination found disassociation with sport and hypersexualization on the covers of the LGBT-themed magazine, a trend that has typically been portrayed among female athletes featured in mainstream magazines.
Stooksberry and Carter examined random magazine covers from 2009-2011. A total of 28 magazine issues were studied 14 magazine covers from each publication.
The analyses reviewed:
- Photo composition
- Location field/court during practice/competition or off the field/court
- Posing Action, strong pose (hands on hips/legs apart), passive (crying after a victory), posed as if they were in action, stationary poses
- Body position Powerful, submissive
- Clothing In uniform, casual or dress clothing, bathing suit, no visible clothing
-
Facial expression Smiling, intense expression
While Sports Illustrated clearly identified cover subjects as athletes even identifying the sport in which they participate subjects on the cover of Compete were largely disassociated from sport, state the authors. In fact, many of the subjects on the cover of Compete could not be identified as athletes and their affiliation with sport was unclear.
The authors found that out of the covers they studied, Compete covers showed athletes on the field/court in 7.1 percent of its cover photos, whereas Sports Illustrated had subjects in the field/court in more than 86 percent of its photos. About a third of the analyzed Sports Illustrated covers featured athletes in motion, while none of the Compete cover photos displayed motion, but rather stationary poses.
The authors also say subjects on the cover of Sports Illustrated were easily identifiable as athletes. Ninety-two percent of the Sports Illustrated covers portrayed athletes in uniform, while 21.5 percent of subjects on Compete were dressed in uniform. Around 14 percent of the Compete covers showed athletes in bathing suits or with no visible clothing.
Female athletes are often sexualized and feminized in a similar fashion to non-athlete women in mass media, write the authors. Male athletes are rarely, if ever, depicted in sexualized, submissive, objectifying or non-athletic positions in sports magazines. Therefore, the disassociation of Compete men from athletics, along with their hypersexualization and objectification, results in a queered form of masculinity.
The researchers say the analysis fills a gap in research examining masculinity within mediated sports.
Related Stories
From literature to AI: UC grad shares career path to success
April 23, 2024
Before Katie Trauth Taylor worked with international organizations like NASA, Boeing and Hershey, and before receiving accolades for her work in the generative AI space, she was in a much different industry: English and literature.
WVXU: Why is part of Green Township called Dent?
April 23, 2024
UC College of Arts and Sciences professor tells WVXU that Ohio's glacial past might explain how Dent got its name.
Local 12: Local universities open Taylor Swift courses
April 22, 2024
In the lead up to the release of Taylor Swift's new album, "The Tortured Poets Department," several media outlets covered classes offered at UC that focus on the singer's music and poetry. UC offers three classes that cover the pop icon: a general music course at CCM and two classes at A&S.