Joseph A. Steger
1984-2003

Henry R. Winkler
1977-1984

Warren G. Bennis
1971-1977

Walter C. Langsam
1955-1971

Raymond Walters
1932-1955

Herman Schneider
1928-1929
1929-1932

Frederick C. Hicks
1920-1928

Charles W. Dabney
1904-1920

Joseph E. Harry
1904

Howard Ayers
1899-1904

Philip Van Ness Myers
1895-1896

William Oliver Sproul
1893-1894

Edward Wyllys Hyde
1892-1893
1894-1895
1896-1898

Wayland R. Benedict
1891
1894

Jacob Dolson Cox
1885-1889

Thomas Vickers
1877-1884

Henry Turner Eddy
1874-1875
1884
1889-1891

George H. Harper
1873

Robert Buchanan
1867-1869

Rufus King
1860-1869

Thomas J. Biggs
1839-1845

Rev. William Holmes McGuffey
1836-1839

Bishop Philander Chase
1822-1823

Rev. Elijah Slack
1819-1822
1823-1836