Want the Shortest Path to the Good Life? Try Cynicism
Are cynics and happiness mutually exclusive? For modern cynics, perhaps. But for the ancient Cynics, not necessarily.
Research by the University of Cincinnatis Susan Prince shows that despite the historical perception of the ancient Cynics as harsh, street-corner prophets relentlessly condemning all passersby and decrying societys lack of virtue, these Greek philosophers, indirectly descended from Socratic teaching, werent all doom and gloom. They actually might have espoused a shortcut to happiness.
We dont have good scholarship on the Cynics. Theyre seen as misanthropes and as sloppy and dirty people who want to cut down the elite, says Prince, UC assistant professor of
, adding, But theres a positive strand that needs to be recovered, and Im really going to punch that hard with my research.
Prince was invited to present her new research paper, Antisthenes and the Short Route to Happiness, during the 13th annual Unisa Classics Colloquium hosted by the University of South Africas Department of Classics and World Languages from Oct. 25-27 in Pretoria. More than a dozen presentations from international scholars will address the conference theme of Ancient Routes to Happiness.
Much of Princes work focuses on the individual believed to be the primary influence on the Cynic movement, Antisthenes.
Antisthenes was a pupil of Socrates and occasional rival of Plato. In fact, while history occasionally paints Plato as a philosopher of unequaled wisdom, UC's Prince says that through study of his texts, its more plausible that he developed his ideas through tight intellectual debates with his contemporaries, and Antisthenes was among them.
ANCIENT CYNICS' RECIPE FOR HAPPINESS: AVOID AN EMPHASIS ON MATERIAL GOODS
Plato and Antisthenes shared many beliefs in common with all philosophers rejection of wealth and luxury, and embracing the pursuit of wisdom and virtue. But Antisthenes methods set him apart from Plato. Whereas Plato founded his Academy for philosophical teaching and lengthy study,
Antisthenes advocated a short but rigorous path toward virtue and happiness
Antisthenes way was short in that he endorsed an abbreviated curriculum when compared to those of other schools of philosophy, which contended that the quick route was a road to nowhere. Antisthenes teachings skipped over the technical aspects of logic in order to concentrate on ethical literature, such as reading Homer.
And Antisthenes way was rigorous in that it required a drastic attitude change.
To follow the path of the Cynic was to abandon many societal conventions and to live in accord with nature no more fancy clothes, no more exquisite feasts and even no more roof over your head.
ANCIENT CYNICS' LACK OF EMPHASIS ON MATERIAL GOODS LED TO MORE LEISURE TIME
Through this shortcut, Prince says
Cynics were able to gain leisure time which could be put toward living the good life or what Antisthenes called seeing the things worth seeing and hearing the things worth hearing. And thats how an ancient Cynic could exist in ethical bliss until the end of his days.
You get to your happiness quickly and then you practice your happiness for the rest of your life, Prince says.
In a modern context, theres some irony in the notion of a cynic devoted to the pursuit of happiness, and Prince hopes her research can clear the air on Antisthenes, et al. In addition to her paper for the Unisa conference, she has a 600-page manuscript on Antisthenes scheduled to be published through the University of Michigan Press in 2013 or 2014. She wants to show that the negative connotation associated with cynic might be historically inaccurate and to provide a little redemption for centuries of misjudgment.
Im resisting the modern sense of cynic, Prince says. That just hits the mission on the head: To recover the ancient Cynics and show that you cant just project straight backward. Theres a whole history there that has led us to our modern sense of the term cynic, and that comes from the negative tradition.
MORE BACKGROUND ON ANTISTHENES AND ANCIENT CYNICS
Plato didnt become great by himself, says UC's Prince. Antisthenes was very important as one of the interlocutors who wasnt always Platos enemy. Their relationship was more like a sibling rivalry.
Rivalry or not, when looking into historys rearview it seems as if Platos shadow has grown larger than it appeared, diminishing the contributions of others. Peter van Minnen, head of the Department of Classics in UCs
, thinks the Cynics have been under represented in the scope of Greek philosophers.
Susan's revised Greek text is explained in more detail than ever before, van Minnen says. Once it is published, all classicists will turn to it for Antisthenes. The Cynics are kind of neglected but good to think with so we don't take Plato and Aristotle as the only gospel in Greek philosophy.
UC student takes in Cannes Film Festival
June 27, 2022
UC student Tanmay Srivastava got a unique point of view on the film industry this year by attending the Cannes Film Festival, an international event held annually in Cannes, France.
Ancient Maya used sustainable farming, forestry for millennia
June 24, 2022
University of Cincinnati researchers found evidence of sustainable agriculture and forestry spanning a millennia in one ancient Mayan city.
Fox19: UC contributes to search for life on Mars
June 24, 2022
UC College of Arts and Sciences associate professor Andy Czaja and his students are on NASA's science team using the Perseverance rover and Ingenuity helicopter to look for evidence of ancient life on Mars.