Humans for Sale: UC Research Helps Raise Awareness of Human Trafficking

Human trafficking –– or the control, ownership and sale of another human being for monetary gain –– was a common occurrence centuries ago, but many believe it doesn't exist in this day and age and not in this country.

“Not so,” says ALyse Zook-DeLange, UC communications graduate student, “The problem still exists all over the world, and right here in our own hometowns.”

While most people view prostitution as a form of human trafficking, DeLange points out that it is really not. Prostitution is a choice, but sex trafficking, one of the five types of human trafficking is not and is the central issue of a comprehensive research paper that DeLange will present in November.

The scope of DeLange’s research centered around the public’s perception of human trafficking gleaned from personal interviews she had conducted with spectators after viewing the “Invisible: Slavery Today” exhibit at Cincinnati’s National Underground Railroad Freedom Center.

DeLange presented the research findings from her master's thesis entitled “Museum as site of meaning: Exploring audience responses to the National Underground Railroad Freedom Center's Invisible: Slavery Today exhibit,” at the National Communications Association Conference in Chicago on Nov. 20. DeLange’s talk was part of the NCA’s first ever, half-day seminar on human trafficking.

Using the visual elements, spatial qualities and overall messages in the Freedon's Center's exhibit, DeLanged reflexively analyzed how the visitors utilized the space to understand the issue of human trafficking. And as part of the two-fold purpose in her research, she combined her own personal perceptions and critiques as another relevant lens.

Through her analysis of the participants’ construction process of the exhibit, DeLange found three overarching themes emerging; how the exhibit constructed and critiqued human trafficking as an American phenomenon, the different facets of human trafficking and the physical features of the exhibit.

Altogether, DeLange proclaims Invisible: Slavery Today as an extraordinarily powerful exhibit that discusses modern day slavery in ways that visitors can interact with and learn from, particularly regarding the new understanding of the scope, gravity and proximity of human trafficking as it exists today.

“Human trafficking and sex trafficking are too often seen as synonymous when indeed they are not,” says DeLange. “Defining what human trafficking really is and the clouded misperception the general public has about this problem was one of the goals of my research, and another goal is to start conversations about this issue.”

Funding and support

DeLange’s fundamental research began as an undergraduate student, spending spring break during her sophomore, junior and senior years of college in India.

The first two trips were volunteering in one of the largest brothel districts in the country, while the last trip involved traveling across the nation to meet and learn from five different anti-trafficking organizations.

During that time DeLange hung out with students on several Indian college campuses discussing the issue of sex trafficking in their city.

“Surprisingly,” says DeLange. “Those students are no more aware of India’s human trafficking problem than Americans are of those same issues here.”

Human trafficking is often perceived as sex trafficking, according to DeLange, but sex trafficking is only one of several ways a human can be enslaved. Bonded labor, forced labor, child labor, and domestic servitude as well as sexual slavery are common forms of human trafficking and DeLange found that it happens in our American hometowns, too.

By taking a very qualitative and interpretive approach to her research, DeLange gives a broad view of the many facets of human trafficking. In the foreground, she looks at:

• How Americans understand the truth about the human trafficking issue
• How Americans respond and handle the issue
  

Her ultimate goal for this project is:

• To understand how people make sense of human trafficking
  
• Start conversations about its reality
  

DeLange found that the general perception of human trafficking is that the victims are kidnapped. And while kidnapping does exist, the true scenario is much more relational than it is a kidnapping situation. Her experiences and research reveal that it more commonly revolves around vulnerability. The traffickers or perpetrators tend to build a relationship with the vulnerable victims and win them over, show them love and attention when they feel like they don’t have any, then slowly manipulate the victims to get them where they want them.

One of the many examples of domestic human trafficking from the exhibit talked about a woman who was brought to the U.S. to be a domestic servant, forced to live in unlivable conditions in a garage and brainwashed into thinking that if she left she would be arrested as an illegal foreigner.  

Another example from one of DeLange's interviews was a ring of men in Southern Indiana who looked for signs of vulnerability in young, single pregnant women who were struggling financially. The men would pose as a boyfriend figure, convince the women to rent an apartment out of their price range by promising to help, then when the women could not continue to pay the rent, the men would force the women to sell their bodies and sometimes their children. Even in a well-known college town less than two hours away, these scenarios play out.

Vulnerability also explains why victims from other countries fall prey to human trafficking. While in India, DeLange traveled to several cities talking with anti-trafficking organizations and asked them to share stories of human trafficking.  She found that scarcity of water has a direct correlation to trafficking in many third-world countries because women frequently had to walk long distances each day to get water. Traffickers would often come into their villages and manipulate them into going with them into the city to get a job that would pay them a lot of money that they could send home to their parents. But when they get there they are instead sold to a brothel owner. The women would most often stay in that situation because they ultimately thought it was the only option.

“Even in the U.S. we still have child labor,” says DeLange. “And we have people who are forced to work, either as illegal immigrants or victims of financial oppression.”

Two key tenets to DeLange’s findings are that most Americans don’t understand the many different forms of human trafficking, and when educated appropriately, they respond with very consumeristic choices when asked what changes they might make now based on their new understanding of the situation.

“What happens now and where do we go from here?” asks DeLange at the end of her interviews. “In response, most people wanted a list of stores who participated in slave labor so they could stop shopping at those stores, or wanted to know where they could donate their money to help stop this abhorrent behavior.”

DeLange explains that these attitudes are ultimately embedded in a very American, Western, capitalistic approach to life whereby we fix this problem by being better or more conscious consumers, or we fix our consumerism so this doesn’t happen, just to name a few.

The results of DeLange’s research have helped direct her into digging deeper into finding solutions for the root causes for the vulnerability and starting conversations that say, “Hey, this is a problem, and what can we do about it?”

Local organizations that help bring awareness:

• End Slavery Cincinnati - endslaverycincinnati.org
• Aruna Project - arunaproject.com
• "2015 Aruna 5K Cincinnati Facebook” will hold its next 5K race on April 15, 2015, at Cincinnati Underground Railroad Freedom Center