The New York Times: Court Declares Man Wrongfully Imprisoned for 45 Years

Ohio Innocence Project client can seek damages for being wrongfully imprisoned

In October, a jury found Isaiah Andrews, an 84-year-old Cleveland man was found not guilty of the 1974 murder of his wife. That came after Andrews spent 45 years in prison before attorneys for the Ohio Innocence Project (OIP) at the University of Cincinnati College of Law were able to help free him.

Last week, a court declared that Andrews had been wrongfully imprisoned. The official declaration this means that that Andrews can seek damages from the State of Ohio for spending more than half his life in prison after being wrongly convicted of killing his wife.

Andrews’ retrial was granted when OIP lawyers discovered that investigators of his wife’s death had another suspect but didn’t share that information with the original jury.

“You would have never known from reading the trial transcripts that the police had arrested someone else for this,” Brian Howe, an OIP attorney told the New York Times for a story.

According to the New York Times, that information became available only in 2019, after OIP lawyers requested that the DNA in the case be tested. The Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation requested files from the original medical examination and was given police files which brought to light the other man’s arrest.

Read the full story in The New York Times online. (Some viewers may need a subscription.)

Learn more about Brian Howe, professor in the UC College of Law, online.

Featured image of OIP attorney Brian Howe with Isaiah Andrews. Photo provided.

Related Stories

1

6 ways starting a GLP-1 medication could affect your emotions

May 20, 2026

When patients first start taking a glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) medication, they probably expect to feel full. But they might not anticipate how it can influence their emotions. The medications act on the stomach and the brain, said Malti Vij, MD, a University of Cincinnati adjunct associate professor in the College of Medicine's Department of Internal Medicine and a diplomate of the American Board of Obesity Medicine.

2

Donald P. Klekamp College of Law at the University of Cincinnati naming celebration

May 19, 2026

Joy reverberated in the atrium at the Donald P. Klekamp College of Law at the University of Cincinnati on Friday, May 15, 2026. Laughter, smiles, heartfelt speeches and an appearance by the Bearcat made for a special afternoon for the family, friends, University of Cincinnati alumni, students, faculty and leadership who gathered to celebrate the renaming of the college.

3

Pocket-sized population threat

May 18, 2026

The Financial Times took a deep dive into why populations around the world continue to be on the decline. The publication cited new University of Cincinnati research as part of the investigation that looks at the fall of fertility in the digital era.