UC’s Ohio Innocence Project helps earn freedom for Cleveland man after more than 14 years in prison

Appeals court described 2006 trial as a ‘travesty of justice’

For the first time in more than 14 years, Michael Sutton and Kenny Phillips are free men.

The two Cleveland men, who were 17 years old at the time of the shooting of two people and the attempted shooting of a Cleveland police officer, were freed on a $50,000 personal recognizance bond Monday, May 3. Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas Judge John O’Donnell ruled both Sutton and Phillips will be out on bond until their new trial begins.

Sutton was represented by UC's Ohio Innocence Project (OIP), while Phillips was represented by the Wrongful Conviction Project (WCP) at the Ohio Public Defender Commission.

Donald Castor, left, of the UC College of Law, with Kenny Sutton

Donald Caster, left, of the UC College of Law, with Kenny Sutton. Photo/Mark Godsey

In 2006, the pair was convicted by a jury on multiple charges, including the attempted murder of a police officer. A judge sentenced Phillips to 61 years in prison, and Sutton, who was the driver of the car, to more than 40 years in prison. Prosecutors had no physical evidence tying Phillips or Sutton to the crime. The entire case rested on the testimony of police officers Daniel Lentz and Michael Keane, who said they saw the drive-by shooter fire from a car that Phillips and Sutton were riding in.

“Michael and Kenny have been in prison for almost 15 years for something they didn’t do,” says Donald Caster, attorney for the Ohio Innocence Project and associate professor of criminal law at the University of Cincinnati College of Law. “The court of appeals said their trial was a ‘travesty of justice.’ We are grateful that they are finally coming home.”

Jurors never heard from police officers John Lundy and Gregory Jones, who have said in affidavits filed in recent years as part of the men’s appeals, that they, too, were at the shooting scene and that officers Lentz and Keane were not where they said they were when the initial shots were fired. Lundy and Jones also said they never heard any shots fired as Lentz and Keane chased down the fleeing men.

The Eighth District Court of Appeals ruled earlier this year that the state knew about Lundy’s and Jones’ conflicting testimony and failed to disclose it, therefore violating the defendants’ rights to a fair trial. The new trial date for Phillips and Sutton has not yet been scheduled.

Representing Phillips for the WCP were attorneys Joanna Sanchez and Rachel Troutman, along with investigators Mark Rooks and Larry VanCant. Attorneys Donald Caster and Sam Kovacevic with UC’s OIP represented Sutton. The current and former UC College of Law students who worked on the case over the years include Nikita Srivastava, Amona Al Refaei, Yessica Cardenas, Jamal Baheth, Ambrosia McKenzie, Claire Gaglione and Rachel Keathley.

OIP has now freed 33 innocent Ohioans who together served more than 650 years in prison for crimes they did not commit.

Lead image/Cleveland.com

Your Next is Now. It Starts Here.

As one of the nation’s smallest urban law schools, we will help you follow your path to fulfill your passion. Our students shine brightest when they are fighting for the disenfranchised, elevating local entrepreneurs, combating economic inequalities, and defending human rights. No matter what path you choose, we’ll make it possible. Learn more today.

Related Stories


Rising temperatures possibly linked to increased city crime rate

June 20, 2024

Criminal Justice expert J.Z. Bennett interviewed by Fox 19 for his expertise on the relationship between rising temperatures and rise in crime. Bennett says there is no single cause to point to for the rise in crime during a heat wave, but that youth involvement in crime might be due to peer pressure and lack of supervision.


Born to run

June 20, 2024

Former professional athletes have advantages in running for political office, UC’s David Niven tells The Atlantic. Niven, an associate professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, teaches a course on sports and politics.

Debug Query for this