UC mock trial team makes elite national competition

Team brings home All-American awards

Each spring, in hundreds of nondescript rooms across the country, around 700 collegiate mock trial teams compete. Team members collaborate to create compelling arguments, for both the mock defense and prosecution, to win their respective cases.

Tensions run high and each team member must be fully prepared and in character to advance to the national competition. Only 7% of all collegiate teams qualify.

The University of Cincinnati's team joined the elite competition this year for the first time since 2019, appearing in April in the American Mock Trial Association’s national championship in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

 UC’s team is comprised mainly of students from the College of Arts and Sciences, with more than two-thirds of the nationals team enrolled in an A&S major.

The UC Mock Trial Team had the unique opportunity of competing with all-female team with co-captains Divya Kumar and Zophia Pittman-Jones leading.

Kumar, who has been on the team since her first year at UC, is a third-year history major. She was awarded an All-American Attorney Award at Nationals.

UC's mock trial team at the 2022 national championship in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

UC's mock trial team at the 2022 national championship in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Credit/Jessica Lorenzo, U of Florida.

“I really doubted myself and my abilities for a long time in mock trial,” Kumar says about her reaction to the award. “This year, I didn’t win any individual awards throughout the season, and it never bothered me, because we were a better team. 

“The difference with an All-American is once you’re an All-American, you have the title for life. At tournaments, judges will introduce themselves as All-Americans. It’s a really big honor.” 

Receiving an All-American award means that the competitor ranked high in their role based on the decision of two to three judges in each round of the competition. Kumar was ranked high in 26 of 30 ranks in her role as a defense attorney. 

Other schools that competed were the University of Chicago, the Washington University of St. Louis, Ohio State University, and Ivy League schools like Harvard and Yale University. Harvard won the competition in the final round against the University of Chicago.

Fellow team member Anna Sciarretti also received an All-American Award but for her role as a witness for the prosecution. She ranked high in 23 out of 30 ranks. 

The competition challenges students in not only their legal knowledge but their performance chops, as well. Sciarretti’s winning character witness spoke with a southern accent and “wasn’t all there,” which she says worked for the case. 

“The strength that I bring is entertainment,” Sciarretti says. “Sometimes it sticks with the judges and sometimes it doesn’t, but it just seemed to stick this time.” 

Sciarretti, a third-year political science and law & society major, joined the team at the beginning of her first year of college at UC. 

“I’m really excited to return next year as an All-American,” Sciarretti says. “I couldn’t have won the award without my team pushing me and my coaches pushing me. Divya and I winning these awards is a win for the entire team, because we couldn’t have done it without their help.” 

Mock trial team co-captains Zophia Pittman-Jones and Divya Kumar celebrate their performance at the national championship competition.

Mock trial team co-captains Zophia Pittman-Jones and Divya Kumar celebrate their performance at the national championship competition. Credit/Jessica Lorenzo, U of Florida.

Zophia Pittman-Jones, team co-captain, UC mock trial president and fourth-year political science student, was on the team when they last went to Nationals in 2019. This trip to nationals, she says, was different. “It felt like a sisterhood,” she says.

Kumar agrees. “Every single person on this team was focused on the team and how we can work together and fill in the gaps for each other,” Kumar says. “And we were focused on having fun.”

Sciarretti mentions the passion each member felt to make it to nationals. “Something that really gave us some fire was that we were extremely close to going to nationals last year,” she says. “We had a lot of fire to prove ourselves this year. The teamwork and how well we all worked together helped us make it to Nationals.”

The UC Mock Trial Team is led by coaches Austin LiPuma, Joshua Leckrone and Nick Plymale, all of whom competed in mock trial in their college careers. One of their responsibilities is putting the team members into roles that will play to their strengths.

“It’s very performative, and a lot of the stuff that we do is not at all realistic, especially with the character witnesses who have goofy accents and jokes, but that’s what makes it more fun, for the judges and the competitors,” Kumar says.

The skills learned in mock trial can help in the classroom and beyond.

“With mock trial, we’re learning a lot of real life, legal terminology and the process of the judicial system. That really helps inform my work with Arts and Sciences and in my classes,” Pittman-Jones says. She also says that her public speaking and memorization skills improved through mock trial.

If you want to go to law school, mock trial is one of the best activities you can sign up for at UC, according to Kumar.

The most important part of mock trial, according to the competitors, has been the friendships made. “I’ve met the closest friends that I’ve ever had in mock trial,” Pittman-Jones says.

Featured image at top: UC mock trial co-captains Zophia Pittman-Jones and Divya Kumar introduce the team at the national championship. Credit/Jessica Lorenzo, University of Florida

Headshot of By Bryn Dippold

By Bryn Dippold

Student Journalist, A&S Department of Marketing and Communication

artscinews@ucmail.uc.edu

Related Stories

UC research institute hosts first annual festival of sensing

May 13, 2022

UC’s Institute for Research in Sensing (IRiS) hosts its first annual Expo & Festival of Sensing next month to convene an interdisciplinary conference exploring the topic of sensing in all its forms, from the sciences to the humanities.   The event will be held on May 25 and 26 in Tangeman University Center, 2600 Clifton Ave., and is open to faculty, staff, students and the public.   The conference brings together representatives from across disciplines—from engineering, biology, ethics, the humanities, performing arts and more—to explore sensing through a variety of lenses, says IRiS director and associate professor of biology Nathan Morehouse.   “We hope the IRiS event raises awareness of the amazing breadth of work happing on sensing at UC, while at the same time stimulating new conversations between the sciences, engineering, the arts and humanities,” he said.  

UC research sheds light on historically marginalized communities

May 12, 2022

At the University of Cincinnati’s College of Art and Sciences (A&S), students are often given the opportunity to complete in-depth research tailored to their individual interests. For two graduate students in the history department, this research included challenging the notion that the only research with impact is done by those in white lab coats. Maurice Adkins and Katherine Ranum have spent their graduate school years bringing to light stories of marginalized people, helping to fill gaps within U.S. historical studies. As a result, many institutions are taking notice of Adkins and Ranum, rewarding them with fellowships that allow them to continue their efforts to make historical research more inclusive. Adkins, a recent graduate from the history department’s doctorate program, spent seven years traveling between Cincinnati and North Carolina, scouring archives and hunting down public records to complete his dissertation, which explores Black leadership at historically Black col- leges and Universities (HBCUs) in North Carolina from 1863-1931. This quickly became laborious, Adkins says, due to the underfunding that many HBCUs have faced historically, resulting in poorer record keeping than that of other universities.

Debug Query for this