Wall Street Journal: The science behind a 'clean beauty' label

Demand for "clean beauty" products continues to grow, but what does that term really mean?

"Clean beauty is not defined in a regulatory sense in the cosmetics industry, so many retailers and brands have come up with their own definitions," said Kelly Dobos, adjunct instructor in the University of Cincinnati James L. Winkle College of Pharmacy's Cosmetic Science program. "It tends to focus on more naturally derived ingredients, as well as ingredients with known safety profiles."

Dobos, who is also an alumna of UC's Cosmetic Science program, walked through specific ingredients of a foundation sold by clean beauty brand Ilia for a Wall Street Journal video filmed in UC's cosmetic science laboratories.

She explained that in foundations, red, yellow and black iron oxide and titanium dioxides are used as primary pigments. 

"Iron oxides are exactly like they sound, they’re basically rust," Dobos said. "Red iron oxide, of course, is probably most familiar. Titanium dioxide is used to tint the foundation to different shades, but it’s also added to increase opacity."

Titanium dioxide can be a carcinogen when inhaled, Dobos said, but it is safe when used in cosmetic formulations. 

"The concern really comes from industrial exposures to workers who might be in manufacturing situations," she said.

Dobos said fillers in cosmetic products often get a "bad rap," but they play an important role in "balancing the feel of a product across the entire range of shades."

"Cosmetic ingredients are listed in descending order of predominance," Dobos added. "That means the greatest concentration of ingredients are closer to the top of the list."

Watch the Wall Street Journal video.

Dobos also discussed clean beauty cosmetics with Fox 19. Watch the Fox 19 segment.

Featured photo at top of makeup and brushes. Photo/July Ko/iStock.

Related Stories

1

On track: Hoffman Honors Scholar studies public transit

April 2, 2026

Public transit is where Zane Sawyer’s lifelong passion for travel meets his commitment to making an impact. The University of Cincinnati first-year geography major in the College of Arts & Sciences and member of the second cohort of Hoffman Honors Scholars (HHS) has hit the ground running, designing a research project intended to capture both how public transit works and how its users perceive it.

2

UC design student works with sports greats in co-op

April 2, 2026

Spectrum News profiles UC College of Design, Architecture, Art, and Planning communication design student Jayden Balwally, who had an internship with the Oklahoma City Thunder and worked with the Heisman Trophy Trust and the College Football Playoff.

3

UC names Suzanne Judd, PhD, as inaugural director of new Center for Public Health

April 2, 2026

Following an extensive national search, the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine has appointed Suzanne E. Judd, PhD, as the inaugural director of its newly established Center for Public Health. Judd, a renowned epidemiologist and interdisciplinary scholar, will lead the center’s mission to transform community health through innovative research, education and strategic advocacy.