UC's OIP confident appeals court will free Cleveland men convicted in drive-by shooting

The fate of two Cleveland men convicted of attempted murder who both maintain their innocence is in the hands of the Ohio 8th District Court of Appeals, and attorneys with the Ohio Innocence Project who are working on their behalf are confident that new evidence in the case could free them, reports Cleveland 19.

Kenny Phillips and Michael Sutton were arrested and charged with the 2006 attempted murder at a Cleveland gas station. Both men had just turned 18. Phillips received more than 92 years, and Sutton 46 years after police say they shot at a vehicle, leaving two people seriously injured, and also at police.

The Ohio Innocence Project (OIP) at the University of Cincinnati College of Law is working on the men’s case, along with the Wrongful Conviction Project.

Donald Caster, an attorney with the OIP, is steadfast that Sutton, now 33, and Phillips, now 32, are innocent, and says that new evidence and discovery in the case could free them both.

“Two Cleveland police officers, one current and one former, have come forward and said the original testimony from other officers doesn’t make sense from what they saw,” Caster said.

Read the full story here.

Featured image at top: UC College of Law building in spring. Dottie Stover/UC Creative + Brand

Related Stories

1

Ohio nurses weigh in on proposed federal loan rule

December 12, 2025

Spectrum News journalist Javari Burnett spoke with UC Dean Alicia Ribar and UC nursing students Megan Romero and Nevaeh Haskins about proposed new federal student loan rules. Romero and Haskins, both seniors, were filmed in the College of Nursing’s Simulation Lab.

3

UC awarded nearly $1 million to help fight infant obesity spike

December 12, 2025

University of Cincinnati researcher Cathy Stough spoke with Spectrum News1 about a nearly $1 million National Institutes of Health grant awarded to UC to help prevent infant obesity through early nutrition support and family-based interventions.