UC study finds vision loss fear may keep some from having cataract surgery
Research underscores importance of doctor-patient trust, communication when making medical decisions
Fear of vision loss may deter some patients from undergoing necessary cataract surgery, according to a newly published study. Cataracts are the leading cause of reversible blindness, and surgery remains the only effective treatment.
The study, recently published in The Journal of Clinical Ophthalmology, highlights the trust patients place in their physicians and the critical role of doctor-patient communication in making medical decisions.
Lisa Kelly, MD, Taylor Asbury-endowed professor-educator and director of medical student education in the Department of Ophthalmology. Photo/Colleen Kelley/University of Cincinnati.
The research was led by Lisa Kelly, MD, a Taylor Asbury-endowed professor-educator and director of medical student education in the Department of Ophthalmology at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine. Kelly also serves as medical director of UC eye clinics. The study’s corresponding author was Samantha Hu, a fourth-year medical student. Stephanie Wey, MD, a former UC resident, and Rainier Yano, a third-year medical student, also contributed.
The research team surveyed 42 patients at Hoxworth Eye Clinic, the training site for UC’s ophthalmology residents located near UC Medical Center. The study explored a possible link between health literacy and fear surrounding cataract surgery.
“We hypothesized that patients with lower health literacy would fear surgery more, especially the risk of vision loss,” said Hu. “But our findings didn’t support that.”
Cataracts develop when proteins in the eye’s natural lens break down and clump together, leading to blurry or dimmed vision. Because the condition is most commonly age-related, those surveyed were all 50 and older. Sixty percent reported a yearly income below $50,000.
Study findings
Among those surveyed, 36% reported fear of cataract surgery, and more than half of those specifically feared it would lead to vision loss. However, researchers found no correlation between this fear and a patient’s health literacy level.
“We found patients who would benefit from surgery reasonably understood the procedure after we educated them,” Kelly said. “But even with clear explanations, sometimes their fear persisted.”
Hu noted that simply providing more information wasn’t always helpful. “Overloading patients with data doesn’t necessarily ease their concerns,” she said.
Instead, the study pointed to the importance of open communication.
"... our patients are people with real fears. Our role is to partner with them in their health care."
Lisa Kelly, MD Taylor Asbury-endowed professor-educator and director of medical student education in the Department of Ophthalmology
“Yes, patient education matters, but it’s not always sufficient,” said Kelly. “What’s equally important is building relationships and trust to help patients overcome fear.”
Hu said the findings emphasize how much patients rely on their physicians to guide them to medical decisions based on their individual needs.
“It underscores the trust patients place in their doctors — and the need for physicians to truly understand their patient population,” said Hu.
Kelly added, “It’s a reminder that our patients are people with real fears. Our role is to partner with them in their health care.”
Moving forward, researchers are likely to delve deeper into patients’ fear around cataract surgery and how physicians can further strengthen doctor-patient relationships.
Path to residency
Samantha Hu, fourth-year medical student at UC who has matched into an ophthalmology residency
Hu is part of the UC College of Medicine’s Class of 2025. She is originally from Greenwood Village, Colorado, a suburb of Denver.
As Hu became more focused on pursuing the ophthalmology specialty, she said she reached out to Kelly about taking part in research and joined the study in her second year of medical school for the data gathering process.
Hu said she was intrigued by this study because of her interest in the social determinants of health, the economic and social conditions that influence differences in people’s health. “Sam and I spent a lot of one-on-one time together as she worked on this research project,” said Kelly. “I got to know her well.”
The results of the study were first presented at a medical conference last year and likely helped Hu stand out in the competitive residency matching process.
“Engaging with a scholarly question in research like this better positions medical students to take a critical look at the literature,” Kelly said.
After she graduates this spring, Hu will begin her ophthalmology residency at Loyola University Chicago.
Next Lives Here
The University of Cincinnati is leading public urban universities into a new era of innovation and impact. Our faculty, staff and students are saving lives, changing outcomes and bending the future in our city's direction. Next Lives Here.
Featured image at top: Closeup view of woman with eye cataract. Photo/Stock/Liudmila Chernetska.
Related Stories
Can coal make a comeback?
February 24, 2026
Bloomberg Law speaks with Joseph Tomain, Dean Emeritus and Wilbert and Helen Ziegler Professor of Law at UC, about the federal government's push to promote use of coal plants for energy generation.
Why do female caribou have antlers?
February 24, 2026
Researchers at the University of Cincinnati discovered that female caribou feed extensively on shed antlers they find while grazing to supplement their diet with important minerals they need to raise calves. This could explain why female caribou, unique among deer, have antlers.
UC alum aims for summer Olympic debut
February 23, 2026
With the 2026 Winter Olympic Games coming to a close, attention now turns to the summer games coming up in Los Angeles in 2028. Beach sprint rowing is a relatively new sport that is surging in popularity due to its inclusion in the 2028 Los Angeles Olympic Games. Spectrum News 1 spoke with Lindner College of Business alum and most-decorated beach sprint rower of all time, Christopher Bak, on his Olympic-sized goals.