Quanta Magazine: UC physicist discusses rare quark anomalies

Theoretical physicist Jure Zupan says we need more data to declare 'new physics'

Quanta Magazine spoke to a University of Cincinnati theoretical physicist for his take on intriguing results from recent experiments at CERN's particle accelerator.

The Large Hadron Collider in Europe has observed unusual and unexpected behavior of B mesons, one of six types of subatomic particles called quarks that make up most of the visible matter in the universe.

According to Quanta, a team composed of hundreds of international researchers at CERN found that the decay of B mesons "conflicts slightly with the predictions of the Standard Model of particle physics, the reigning set of equations describing the subatomic world."

The team observed 4,500 rare B meson decays. From Quanta:

Statistically, the deviation in the angular pattern is equivalent to flipping a coin 100 times and getting 66 heads, rather than the usual 50 or so. For a fair coin, the odds of such a deviation are about 1 in 1,000.

But amid oodles of particle collisions, statistical fluctuations are bound to arise, so a 1-in-1,000 deviation doesn’t count as hard proof of a break with the Standard Model.

If this is new physics, it's not significant enough.

Jure Zupan, UC theoretical physicist in Quanta Magazine

UC theoretical physicist Jure Zupan told Quanta that researchers must accumulate enough B meson decays to demonstrate a deviation of 1 in 1.7 million. This is the equivalent of getting heads 75 times in 100 coin tosses.

"If this is new physics, it's not significant enough," he said.

Zupan, a professor of physics in UC's College of Arts and Sciences, was the 2019 winner of the prestigious Friedrich Wilhelm Bessel Award from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation in recognition of his lifetime achievement in research on dark matter, antimatter and quarks.

Zupan said research at particle physics labs around the world help us get closer to understanding the origins of the universe.

"The main question we’re addressing is: Why are we here? How is it possible?” he said. “Why did matter dominate over antimatter? It’s a fundamental question of particle physics. We still don’t know the answer.”

Read the Quanta story.

Featured image at top: A cloud of interstellar gas billows around the Carina Nebula captured by NASA's Hubble Space Telescope. Photo/NASA Goddard

Jure Zupan stands at a blackboard full of equations.

University of Cincinnati physicist Jure Zupan has worked at particle accelerator labs around the world. Photo/Joseph Fuqua II/UC Creative + Brand

Related Stories


UC students plan documentary in Eastern Europe during the war 

December 2, 2022

As global media descends on Eastern Europe to cover Russia’s war in Ukraine, two University of Cincinnati students are planning to cover the region from a different angle. Hunter Shallcross and Tanmay Srivastava, both digital media collaborative majors in the College of Arts and Sciences, have planned a trip to multiple European countries to film their own documentary, titled “The Edge of Chaos.” The trip is scheduled for May of 2023.  The pair became friends through their passion for film, and soon started partnering on projects. Last February, Shallcross and Srivastava became interested in the way culture and art are changing in countries on the edge of Europe due to the war, and decided to develop the idea into a documentary. “Everybody is flocking to Eastern Europe to document what is going on. We want it to show the artistic side,” says Shallcross. “The shots, the camera angles, and the narrative we want to tell about relationships and personal issues that go beyond war.”  They began pitching their documentary idea to various professors and making any connections they could to bring their idea to life. Last May, they even attended the Cannes Film Festival, to get some first-hand film experience, while networking with people there. 

Debug Query for this