The Repository: Stark County man released from prison four years after wrongful conviction

Aaron Culbertson is the Ohio Innocence Project’s 38th exonerated client

A Canton man wrongfully convicted and imprisoned of aggravated robbery was released Wednesday thanks to the efforts of the Ohio Innocence Project at the University of Cincinnati College of Law.

Aaron Culbertson, now 20, was arrested on Feb. 14, 2018, when was 16 years old and charged with one count of aggravated robbery, found guilty and sentenced to eight years of prison. Culbertson has been released following new evidence that showed he had been misidentified as a perpetrator of the robbery, and subsequently two other individuals have been identified as the actual culprits of the Feb. 3, 2018 robbery.

Culbertson’s release was supported by Stark County Prosecutor Kyle L. Stone. 

Canton’s daily newspaper, The Repository, covered Culbertson’s release.

Brian Howe, exoneree Charles Jackson (exoneree), Kyle Stoner (Stark County prosecutor), and Aaron Culbertson

Left-to-right: UC Law's Brian Howe, exoneree Charles Jackson, Kyle Stone, who is the Stark County prosecutor, and Aaron Culbertson are shown. Photo provided.

“In March, law students working as Fellows for the Ohio Innocence Project met with Prosecutor Kyle Stone and presented the evidence showing that Aaron Culbertson is innocent,” said Mark Godsey, Ohio Innocence Project director and a UC Law professor. 

“Prosecutor Stone’s office then did a full investigation over many months that confirmed the findings presented by OIP. Stone then joined OIP’s motion to exonerate and free Aaron Culbertson.

“Prosecutor Stone deserves an immense amount of credit for putting politics aside and doing the right thing in this case. Frankly, we don’t see that sort of courage from other elected prosecutors as often as we should. Most don’t want to admit a mistake could have occurred. We are grateful to Prosecutor Stone for bringing freedom back to an innocent man.”

OIP staff attorney Brian Howe represented Culbertson, who is the 38th client to be freed in the Ohio Innocence Project’s 20-year history, and the second within a week. Last Thursday, a Columbus man, Alan J. Butts was released after wrongfully serving 20 years in prison.

Read the full story in The Repository.

Learn more about the work of Ohio Innocence Project online.

Featured image of the Scale of Justice courtesy of Unsplash.

Related Stories

1

6 ways starting a GLP-1 medication could affect your emotions

May 20, 2026

When patients first start taking a glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) medication, they probably expect to feel full. But they might not anticipate how it can influence their emotions. The medications act on the stomach and the brain, said Malti Vij, MD, a University of Cincinnati adjunct associate professor in the College of Medicine's Department of Internal Medicine and a diplomate of the American Board of Obesity Medicine.

2

Donald P. Klekamp College of Law at the University of Cincinnati naming celebration

May 19, 2026

Joy reverberated in the atrium at the Donald P. Klekamp College of Law at the University of Cincinnati on Friday, May 15, 2026. Laughter, smiles, heartfelt speeches and an appearance by the Bearcat made for a special afternoon for the family, friends, University of Cincinnati alumni, students, faculty and leadership who gathered to celebrate the renaming of the college.

3

$15 million bequest supports endowed chair at UC College of Medicine

May 19, 2026

As a student and resident at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, George G. Bemis, Jr., MD, Med ’64, saw firsthand that medicine was more than a profession for those teaching and leading him. Inspired by their sense of calling, he knew he wanted to pursue the same path.