UC study uncovers unexpected link between police spending, housing prices
Breaking down the data by income level reveals large but opposite moves in home prices
A first-of-its-kind study on the link between police budgeting and the housing market seemed to be a dead end — showing practically no relation between the spending on law enforcement and home transaction volume and prices, just like previous studies.
But University of Cincinnati economics professor David Brasington found surprising results when he split the data between low-income and high-income communities: large, completely opposite moves in housing prices.
Brasington, PhD, published a new study called “The Effect of Increased Police Spending on House Prices and Sales Volume: A Tale of Two Types of Cities.” In it, he wrote that “the small or nonexistent link between house prices and crime found by the literature really just reflects the sum of large but opposite moves in house prices in different market segments.”
His research, published in the Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, found that voting to increase the police budget raises housing prices by about 13% in low-income communities, but lowers housing prices by at least 14% in high-income communities.
David Brasington, PhD, James C. and Caroline Kautz Chair in Political Economy and professor at Lindner College of Business, Department of Economics. Photo/University of Cincinnati.
“Nobody had split the sample between the higher- and lower-income areas,” he said. Without splitting the data, the results virtually cancel each other out. Those huge swings on opposite sides of the income range were hidden in plain sight, he said, even as economic theoretical models supported the existence of an effect of police spending on housing.
“Just intuitively, you’d think that police services would make a difference in house prices. And it just wasn’t there in the data,” he added, “until you split the sample.”
In his study, Brasington analyzed communities across Ohio by looking into decades of votes on taxes to increase police funding by an average of 15%. He then compares that to Ohio’s housing data from 1995 to 2018.
At the onset of his research, Brasington’s plan was to compare police tax renewals and home sale volumes. Overall, the data showed little change in volume and prices after a police funding levy. Even after dividing his sample by income, he says that there is seemingly no link between police spending and the quantity of houses sold in a community. But the decrease in home prices for high-income communities and increase in home prices in low-income communities remained consistent for at least five years following the police budget vote.
Brasington says that the decrease in housing prices on the high end suggests police may be overfunded in richer communities. “If you cut police taxes and services, the high end views that as a good thing,” he said. “There would be an increased demand for those houses because of the tax cut and a decreased supply of houses,” he added.
He also says there could be value in looking into how other types of levies impact home prices, and what these big swings on high- and low-income areas mean for the middle class, in future research.
But for lower-income communities, he says the data from this report suggests additional spending on crime-fighting could be worth it. “There’s something about housing demand that says, ‘We need more police funds,’” he said.
Next Lives Here
The University of Cincinnati is classified as a Research 1 institution by the Carnegie Commission and is ranked in the National Science Foundation's Top-35 public research universities. UC's medical, graduate and undergraduate students and faculty investigate problems and innovate solutions with real-world impact. Next Lives Here.
Featured image at top of police car. Photo/iStock/Halbergman
Related Stories
Bearcats ONEchat and Projects will launch the week of Nov. 16
November 12, 2026
Bearcats ONEchat and Projects will be available to all BearcatsGPT users beginning the week of Nov. 16. Together, the new features represent the university's continued effort to provide accessible, user-friendly AI tools that support teaching, learning, research and administrative work across the university community.
Cincinnati Stride event to help young people who stutter build confidence
November 12, 2026
For children who stutter, speaking can sometimes be frustrating, anxiety-inducing and a source of low confidence. The University of Cincinnati is a host of Cincinnati Stride, formerly Fluency Friday, which gives kids a chance to connect with others who understand what they're going through. Event organizers recently appeared on both WLWT-TV and WKRC-TV to raise awareness ahead of the free workshop.
Bearcats build brighter futures together — join us on Giving Tuesday
November 12, 2026
Giving Tuesday returns to the University of Cincinnati on Dec. 1 demonstrating the far-reaching impact of the Bearcat community.